The Division of Instruction and Staff Development of the Maryland State Department
of Education, in collaboration with Maryland educators, has developed and compiled
Performance-Based School Improvement Exemplars. These exemplars are designed to
enhance understanding of the principles and practices of performance-based instruction and
assessment. In addition, the exemplars provide models for applying those principles and
practices to help students achieve Maryland Learning Outcomes. Thus, they support
improved school and student performance on the Maryland School Performance Assessment
Program (MSPAP).
The primary purpose of the exemplars is to provide resources for staff development.
It is suggested that you use these exemplars in conjunction with the nine public release tasks
from the 1992 and 1993 MSPAP, as well as those that will be released in the future.
Although these exemplars have undergone limited field testing, they are not necessarily
appropriate for use in all classrooms or for all students at the designated grade levels.
Teachers must make instructional decisions regarding the relevance of a particular exemplar,
where it fits into local school system curriculum and how it matches the developmental
levels of the students they teach.
The format for the exemplars is designed to serve two major functions: to support
the MSPAP format, and to create a flexible framework for a variety of teaching styles,
approaches and methodologies. It is not intended as an exclusive model of performance-
based instruction or assessment.
The exemplars in this packet include three instructional tasks and one assessment
task. It is important to note some differences and similarities between instructional tasks and
assessment tasks. Instructional tasks may vary significantly in the nature of teacher
involvement required as a task progresses. The teacher may be actively directing class, group
or individual instruction throughout, as in the seventh grade task, A Sea of Troubles. Or,
the teacher may serve as a facilitator/coach, as in the eighth grade task, What’s the Object?
In all instructional tasks the teacher is the decision-maker for determining student needs and
for reteaching and revision as appropriate for an individual student or group of students.
Assessment tasks, however, require little or no teacher involvement during student
completion of activities. These tasks are meant to evaluate mastery of particular outcomes,
not to instruct. Other significant differences between instructional tasks and assessment
tasks can include time allotments for completion of activities, types of cooperative learning
that can be used and the range of learning experiences, resources and materials that can be
provided. One example of time allotment differences is apparent when comparing the
instructional task, The Top Ten, which includes an option requiring instructional time over
an entire year, with the eighth grade assessment, America Goes to the Fair, a seventy-five
minute task.
The most significant similarities are that all tasks focus on Maryland Learning
Outcomes, emphasize understanding by engaging students in thoughtful application of
knowledge, processes and skills, and result in student products and performances.
Performance-Based School Improvement Exemplars, Social Studies, Grades 6-8,
is part of the set of social studies exemplars prepared for publication, and is being released
along with exemplars for grades K-3 and 4-5. Teachers may wish to contact the social
studies supervisor or teachers in other grades to obtain copies of these tasks. Examining
exemplars written for different grade levels would provide an opportunity to analyze a
broader range of strategies and methodologies appropriate for performance-based instruction
in social studies.
Exemplars in mathematics and science grades K-3 are also being released, along with
instructional exemplars in science, grades 2, 4 and 7, developed for HyperCard. Exemplars
in mathematics and science grades 4-5 and 6-8 were released in February, 1995. The next
phase of the project will focus on Reading and Writing exemplars, with a planned release
date in the spring of 1996.
Kay A. Birukoff, Ph.D., Chief, Arts and Sciences Branch